On coherence, emergence, and what forty-some strangers grew in three days in the North Dakota Badlands.
On the third morning, Vern gently asked me, "Isn't it risky to trust in emergence?"
Vern is a retired CEO who grew up picking rocks on a North Dakota farm. He'd spent two days watching a room with no agenda find its way, and had told the circle on the first morning, "I'll be honest. This is about as far out of my comfort zone as I've ever been in my life." He was holding the question any thoughtful leader would ask. I told him yes. Completely risky. The wager is that if each of us finds the place of compassion in ourselves and holds it steadily enough, something regenerates by its own design, and it crosses thresholds of difference that no argument can cross. We can't make that happen. We can only create the conditions and see.
For twenty-five years the people who study America's social fabric have measured it from the outside: how many clubs, how many neighbors, how much trust. Our retreat was a practice in what those measures leave out, the interior condition of the people doing the connecting, and the field that seems to form when enough of us tap into that coherence together. Three days in the Badlands were the laboratory. Here is what held, what broke, and what grew.
• •
The room
Medora, North Dakota, has 160 residents and one presidential library. Theodore Roosevelt first came here in 1883, at twenty-four, to hunt. The next February he lost his wife and his mother on the same day, and he came back. He said later he would never have been president without North Dakota. The land held what he couldn't.
Zoe Weil, one of our volunteers, described the week to her friends afterward:
"I have spent an extraordinary week in Medora, North Dakota, with people who came together without knowing what would emerge from our gathering. We were farmers and educators, artists and business leaders, former CIA and government policy makers, pastors and atheists, entrepreneurs and community organizers, lawyers and activists. Mostly, we were simply humans willing to open our hearts to one another, listen, and find in our common humanity and vulnerability the deepest and most perennial truths. It was a gift beyond measure in the Badlands. It was heart in the heartland. I leave carrying the wisdom of so many and with so many sustaining hugs, including multiple hugs with my new North Dakota farmer friend Ron, who employs people in recovery from drug addiction, and whom I hugged repeatedly standing on a chair because he's 6'8"."
Everything was offered as a gift. Nobody was paid to speak. Those who came before had covered the costs, and anyone could pay it forward to a future circle, though no one asked. There was no agenda beyond four days named Ground, Roots, Field, Seed, eight questions on cards, and a fire on the last day.
Most of what we do, we do by reaching for a destination and paving a road of small transactions to get there. I give you this, you give me that, and the road gets built. It works. It also keeps us exactly the size of our exchanges. Take the transactions away and what's left is spaciousness. Rumi called it the field beyond wrongdoing and rightdoing; the Buddha might have added, beyond pleasure and pain. In that spaciousness the heart cracks a little, and friendships form that nobody arranged. Because nobody arranged them, their tensile strength is high. Trust rises. Emergence is happening anyway; the question is what it meets.
What we already know about "we"
In 2000, Robert Putnam published Bowling Alone and gave a name, social capital, to the thing communities run on: networks of relationship and the norms of reciprocity and trust that grow inside them. By every measure he could find, it had been declining since the mid-1960s. Twenty years later, he and Shaylyn wrote The Upswing, tracing 125 years of data to a single arc: America climbed from a culture of "I" to a culture of "we" from the 1890s to the 1960s, then slid back. The lesson was hopeful. We did it once; we can do it again.
David Brooks took a different road to the same place. In 2018 he founded Weave at the Aspen Institute and went listening for the people who hold communities together, the ones who run the coffee shop where everyone feels at home. He called them weavers and argued that the country's problems are relational problems, solvable on the block rather than in Washington. Shaylyn helped him found it.
I honor all of this. Join a club. Weave. Rebuild the norms. But two things inside that body of work came into the room more sharply than a book can bring them.
The first is a caveat the authors of The Upswing make themselves: the great American "we" of the mid-century came with people left out of it. On Tuesday morning, as Shaylyn walked us through the curve, that caveat stopped being a footnote. Someone asked. “Whose ‘we’ are we talking about?” The decades on the chart held internment camps and Jim Crow. The question was fair, and it hurt, and it was ours to hold.
The second is something Brooks found on his listening tour and wrote down honestly: the weavers were lonely. They loved helping, and they noticed no one was there to serve them in their exhausted moments. Twenty-five years of research into social capital, and the person doing the weaving is unaccounted for. Bill O'Brien, who ran Hanover Insurance, put it in a sentence that opened our invitation:
The success of an intervention depends on the interior condition of the intervener.
I had been thinking about that interior condition recently — what it means to become hollow enough to hold a strong view without either disappearing into it or becoming it.
That is the blind spot, and it isn't Putnam's or Brooks's personally; it belongs to the frame. Shaylyn, after twenty-five years of the data, told us she has landed at exactly this. Heart work. Not head work, not bridge building, not platform making, not movement building. Staying in coherence in yourself, in a way that becomes host to the highest good in the other.
So that's what we did together. For three days.
Difference is everywhere
One myth needs clearing first: that the problem is difference and the solution is finding people like us.
Put two Christians in a room and they'll differ. Two Muslims, two billionaires, two farmers. A husband and wife. You and I could smell the same rose, and neuroscience is fairly clear that I have no idea what that was like for you. If sameness were the ground of trust, no one would ever trust anyone.
St. Francis asked, in his prayer, to seek to understand rather than to be understood. It reads as humility. I think it's also a mechanism. The person trying to be understood is broadcasting; the one trying to understand is receiving; and a room of receivers has a different physics than a room of broadcasters. When absence meets absence, you get polarity. When presence meets absence, there's a chance of healing. When presence meets presence, something starts to regenerate.
Coherence, then, is not agreement. It's a quality of the receiver.
Coherence has conditions
The volunteers who host these retreats work from something we call the 5% Manual. The menu, the mics, the airport runs, the questions on the cards: that's the five percent, yours to do early and lightly and as an offering. The other ninety-five percent is the field's to give. When you give, you want to give more; the reward for service is more service. The HeartMath Institute has even tried to measure this: in their studies, one person's heart rhythm shows up in the nervous systems of people nearby, and what predicts it is not how close they stand but how coherent the receiver is. I don't lean on the instruments. The stories below show it better. But it's a useful image to carry into the room.
The five percent looked like this. Taylor hauled carloads of breakfast and snacks from five hours away. Giang held each participant in her morning meditation; Zoe hand-drew a piece of art for every one of them. Tu's visa from Vietnam was rejected, then approved through some grace routed through North Dakota, and her passport arrived the day before a thirty-hour journey. Leoncarlo drove nineteen hours from Texas with a violin and never asked what he'd be playing for. JT practiced mandalas with her twelve-year-old before she left home. Blaine packed his turntables in case more music was needed. Sheel and Tom, who had never met, ran cameras all week while fending off the prairie's flies, and became a unit. Audrey held every one of the unending details.
Here is some of the ninety-five.
Presence.
Vern was, by his own estimate, one of the eldest in the circle. He told us on the first morning that his father, a stoic German, never once said I love you out loud. When Vern was sixty-eight and still working, his phone recorded a voicemail: I want you to know I love you. Two days later his father died. "Don't wait until you're on the voicemail." Ron, who farms heavy clay and employs people in recovery, described leaving the house at 3 a.m. Monday and coming home at 7 p.m. Wednesday, and when Chalon asked whether that meant he didn't sleep, he lit up: "I just love the work. It's just me and God on the tractor." Chalon starts her mornings barefoot on a lawn in California thanking God for the grass. Different landscape, same prayer. On the farmers' panel a conventional farmer and a permaculture teacher sat side by side and both wept describing the soil.
Circle.
On the first night, Chaz quoted Maya Angelou: “I come as one, but I stand as ten thousand,” and asked everyone to say aloud, at once, the names of the people who had made it possible for them to be there. A cacophony of names. The circle then has to hold whatever walked in behind those names.
On Monday night, it held a fiddle. JT had packed her whole house into a truck and, at the last minute, put in her father's fiddle. He took his own life eighteen years ago; no one had played it since. Janessa's grandmother, it turned out, was a Juilliard violinist who left Manhattan for a farm in Idaho where every night was a fiddle jam. Janessa hadn't played in years. She and Leoncarlo discovered at dinner that they both knew “Ashokan Farewell,” and neither knew, when Whitney suggested it, what had happened to JT's father. The fiddle rose again under hundreds of lights that a volunteer had 3D-printed and screwed in one at a time.
The circle also held two ruptures. The question of “whose we?” And, that same night, a story told truthfully from one person's wound that landed on other people's, and two of them, respectfully, left early. There was no neat resolution. As it happened, both fell on Samvatsari, the Jain day of forgiveness, and on the last morning we held the prayer that Jains say once a year: for whatever harm I have caused any living being, knowingly or unknowingly, I ask forgiveness. It makes no claim of innocence. Chalon named afterward a question worth holding: what happens when we meet at the heart and hurt each other anyway? Because we will.
The wager isn't that a circle prevents hurt. The wager is that a circle can stay present even when hurt enters it.
That asks something of us, too: to widen the aperture of the heart enough to recognize forms of love we may not naturally understand.
I don't know for sure, Luke and I might not see eye to eye on politics. Yet, it never stopped us from hugging. During one break, I told him I saw a child's innocence in his eyes. He lit up. "I have a five-year-old who is non-verbal. We communicate through our eyes. He tells me 'I love you' through his eyes, and I do the same." His views didn't disappear. It just stopped being the whole story. As Chalon wrote afterward, no one is only what is hardest for us to hold about them.
Emergence.
Shaylyn's ancestors crossed these plains on foot, pulling handcarts, and were driven out at gunpoint every time they built their vision of we. At Harvard in 2000, she walked into the first seminar Putnam ever taught on Bowling Alone. In 2004, a young man in Fargo read the book, looked up Putnam's number, and cold-called his office about a community project. Shaylyn was the research assistant who answered. Greg was the young man. They figured this out at dinner in Medora, twenty-two years later.
Ron had read everyone's bios beforehand and texted Greg to please find someone to take his place among such accomplished change-makers. Greg texted back: No. On the second morning, Ron walked into the breakfast room and hugged every person in it. On the last night, under a sky with no town to dim it, Nav sat shivering with cold and transcendence inside an oversized sweater Ron had put on him and refused to take back. The next day, Nav accidentally left his own jacket at the lodge; Taylor picked it up to bring to him in Boulder, they missed each other, and he told her to give it to someone who needs it.
What scales
I recently read about an elderly man in Texas hauling luggage up stairs for pay, though he was too frail for it, to cover his wife's cancer bills. A neighbor saw, started a fundraising page, and it went viral. He ended up with a million dollars.
My first response was tears. My second was to imagine a world where every such circumstance was held with that grace, and to notice that today's designs make it structurally impossible. A viral campaign needs the right performative framing for an eight-second attention span, on a platform that profits from the performance, and if everyone managed it, the platform would raise the threshold. Gandhi had a design principle for this. Sarvodaya, the welfare of all, which as I read it refuses to burn one bridge to build two others. Our platforms make us compete for the mic; by construction, they can't reach the welfare of all.
What if that man had been held by his own community, in a way that worked for him? That's the story Shaylyn told about her faith: when she moved to a small town in New Hampshire, twenty strangers unloaded her house in an afternoon because she'd called the local congregation. In Surat, in India, eighteen volunteers formed what they call a noble friendship circle. They meet monthly with no agenda. When one of them received a hard diagnosis around diabetes and fell into helplessness, the other seventeen quietly gave up sugar for a month. Nobody announced it. It created a new threshold for the eighteenth person, and everything changed.
That is social capital. Not with people who look like us or think like us, but with people trying to understand more than to be understood. Rosa Parks was not the first Black woman in Montgomery to refuse to give up her seat; Claudette Colvin did it nine months earlier, at fifteen. Parks' act took root because of years of relationship beneath it: a decade as secretary of the local NAACP alongside E.D. Nixon, a summer workshop at the Highlander Folk School just months before, and Jo Ann Robinson's Women's Political Council, which had been waiting for the right moment and printed thirty-five thousand leaflets overnight. Brooks makes a useful distinction here. A relationship happens one person at a time, so it can't be scaled; you can't mass-produce twenty strangers who unload your truck. But a norm can be. When a small group lives a different way and the people around them start copying it, what spreads is not the relationship but the shared sense of what people like us do. That's how a culture changes.
What the retreat leaves me wondering is whether a third thing scales, sitting between the two: a field. It forms among particular people, the way a relationship does, and yet it reaches people who were never in the room, the way a norm does, because coherence is contagious and nature does the copying.
The field doesn't check who's on the guest list. Shannon, the lunch caterer, told Taylor on the last day that they don't usually put food out in the nice bowls, but something about this group made them want to. The big-hearted woman who cleaned the Airbnbs and whom we honored at our community night alongside a sitting senator, texted afterward: "I am still thinking about your whole group. The ironic timing of you being here and me meeting you all blows my mind. You people did more for me than you'll ever realize. It was quite an eye opener for me and you helped me with some things I've been struggling with for a long time. Thank you." And Tom, who introduced himself as a simple carpenter and ended up as our tech guy, candidly wrote that he'd found himself crying in his bathroom with a renewed faith in humanity, and in himself. "It's allowed me a new way to view the world. In a time I really needed a new view."
Here's Leoncarlo on the second community night — an impromptu offering in Medora:
Seeds
A few days later Leoncarlo was playing at a farmers market in Fargo. Someone asked what he charged. "I'm here in love. No payment." Then he started talking about Nav, and a question Nav had left him holding: what if giving and receiving can both come from a place of love?
Grace wrote: "Our souls are filled. Our minds are on fire." She wants her daughter to bring JT's Pile of Puppies to their town in Connecticut. Ruth, who had turned down speaking slots at TEDxFargo for years, now says she has a dozen talks ready to flow out, and is planning one with Rhonda. Rick, who turned seventy-eight the night before we began and told the feedback form that the week had brought him back to full life, has started making nature mandalas in his town in Illinois; Sue, inspired by Rick, has opened a Little Free Library. Cris is in conversation to bring a circle like this to Brazil. Two of the volunteers are hosting a twenty-one-day retreat. Bonnie has been telling stories from the lodge at her church in Ventura; Chalon wrote three essays for her students. Rahul carried home a plaque with a ladle on it and wrote that his door has no lock and no ledger; then he wrote about Roosevelt, who mediated the peace that ended the Russo-Japanese War through two Japanese diplomats who'd been his Harvard classmates twenty years earlier, and asked what the twenty-year ripples of an unlikely room in Medora might be. Janessa flew home into a family emergency and wrote to the group that the word she carried out of North Dakota was trust; emergence, she said, over emergency. Whitney went home to Southern California, followed a car with North Dakota plates out of long-term parking, and laughed. She'd texted a board member that hearts joined was now their metric. He wrote back: hearts first.
And the stories are barely beginning to bud.
• •
Bonnie wrote to me afterward with the question she can't put down: is this enough? In the face of what we're facing, is it enough to practice quiet virtues and let what wants to emerge, emerge? She said she knows it should be, and that she and her community have trouble keeping faith with it. Then she mentioned she'd been to a gathering that day about hate messages left at a local synagogue, and had been struck by the room's willingness to let fierce, dedicated love do the work.
I don't have a better answer than hers. Years ago in Austria, at a gathering not unlike this one, someone said that every place is the center. In Medora it turned out to be a description rather than a sentiment. A town of 160, a lodge at a Bible camp, a caterer's bowls, a fiddle in a truck. The field doesn't wait for the important places to do its work. It does five percent through whoever shows up and carries the rest.
Rick is seventy-eight. On the second morning in Medora, the center of our circle held a mandala he'd helped make from whatever the land had to offer that day: creek stones, foxtail grass, a single marigold. He calls them earth mandalas and has been making them for years. Nothing in them comes from anywhere else. They last a morning. Then the wind takes them, and he makes another. He wrote to Giang afterward that he's going to keep making them back home in Princeton, Illinois, where, as it happens, a flower shop is about to open, and that he wants them to show "the beauty of living things beyond their use for mere decoration."
A town of 160 people. A circle of strangers. A few stones and a flower, put in relationship for one morning. The prairie has been asking the question longer than any of us: what grows here?
Share a Reflection
Your thoughts will be shared with the author